Costello's Pub Text Title
Costello's Pub Sword
Costello's Pub Sign Photo
"About the pub"

Costello’s Pub is a no-frills hideaway where the beer is beer and the whiskey is whiskey. Like everything good about the Midwest, it’s housed in an unfinished basement.

But yeah, no, yeah--it's as warm, welcoming, and busy as an above-ground Irish pub. Don't think "drywall." Think "dim light, exposed beams, well-worn bar top."

Our goal is to turn neighbors into friends over pitchers of cheap beer and Jameson shots lined up on pool tables.

Join us down--but not out--in the basement at Costello's Pub.

"Events at the pub"
Event poster for The Donerick Boys Malort Night on Tuesday, November 18th, 2025 at 8:00 PM, featuring hands pouring Malört liquor shots over a splash effect above a yellow-tinted house.
Stranger things invitation graphic
New Year's Eve party invitation featuring a suburban house with the New York City skyline and Statue of Liberty in the background, with fireworks and a glowing 2025-2026 NYE Party sign.
Costello's Pub Tap Handle Photo
"What's on tap?"A photo of the garage beer logo with text telling you that it's a 4% ABV light beer.
"Location"

ASK A PUNK

"Hours"

MONDAY - THURSDAY

Usually no, but maybe yes. idk..

FRIDAY - SUNDAY

If there’s an away crew game going on then yes, we are probably open. BUT also, maybe not...

Email Icon Button
Instagram Icon Button
stationary map image
Legal: Costello's Pub is not a real pub. We do not sell anything. Don't come after me, IRS. I just got bored and wanted to create a fake website.